Correlating maintenance, energy efficiency and fuel poverty for traditional buildings in the UK
A scoping study funded by Cadw, Historic Environment Scotland and Historic England
The study seeks pathways to demonstrate that better maintenance of traditional buildings could reduce energy costs in the context of climate change. The project was funded by three government agencies; Historic England, Historic Environment Scotland and Cadw. The new British Standard for conservation has already triggered recognition of the correlation of dampness to energy efficiency, here we aimed to address further means to link building condition to building performance.
The depiction of traditional buildings as poorly-performing in terms of energy use incentivises retrofits. It has already been established that baseline scenarios require revision based on in situ measures of thermal performance (BRE, 2015). Other research highlights the risks to historic built fabric that emerge from ill-conceived measures (Fouseki and Cassar, 2014). Both methods used for summarising the physical thermal performance of traditional built fabric as well as presumptions of occupant use and behaviour can risk leading to prejudicial conclusions and erroneous decisions. The goal here is to seek the means to develop more informed approaches to the assessment of energy performance in existing buildings.
A pdf copy of the study is available here.
Mapping layers of history, use and meaning for sustainable planning and conservation:
Our incipient network is devoted to developing more inclusive, informed and sustainable planning decisions for public spaces in historic Indian cities.
This initial project is carrying out a pilot study in the walled city of Ajmer and nearby Pushkar, Rajasthan. These are thriving centres of pilgrimage for different faiths, attracting thousands of devotees at festival times. A rapid growth in tourist numbers has exacerbated the stress on infrastructure. The research focuses on the role of the beliefs and associations, ritual processes, and behavioural patterns of devotees and visiting pilgrims, in order to establish these as crucial factors in the design and conservation of public spaces with religious significance.
To this end, we are trying to create prototypes of digital tools to contain images and information about the city, its history and heritage and to allow reflection, exchange and dialogue among different groups. The interactive models will be put online to be supplemented and critiqued. Findings from the study will be fed to the relevant authorities.
- Prizeman, O.et al. 2017. Modelling from the past: the leaning southwest tower of Caerphilly Castle 1539-2015. ISPRS Annals of Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences IV-2/W, pp. 221-227. (10.5194/isprs-annals-IV-2-W2-221-2017)
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2016. HBIM and matching techniques: considerations for late 19th and early 20th century buildings. Journal of Architectural Conservation 21(3), pp. 145-159. (10.1080/13556207.2016.1139852)
- Whitman, C. and Prizeman, O. E. C. 2016. In situ U-Value monitoring of traditional and modern infill panels of a 15th Century Cruck-framed dwelling, in Herefordshire UK. Association of Preservation Technology Bulletin
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2016. Maintenance of shared spaces: courtyards of Tbilisi. Journal of Cultural Heritage Management and Sustainable Development (10.1108/JCHMSD-11-2015-0043)
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2013. 'Reading Rooms : The Library: A World History' James W.P. Campbell with photographs by Will Pryce Thames & Hudson 2013; 'Contemporary Library Architecture: A Planning and Design Guide' Ken Worpole Routledge 2013 [Book Reviews]. Architectural Review 2013(Dec), pp. 105-106.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2013. Library: Speaking volumes: Bisset Adams' Watney Market Idea Store. Architecture Today AT241, pp. 24-33.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2013. Book mountain: MVRDV's library in Spijkenisee, Rotterdam. Architectural Review, pp. 41-52.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2013. Learning to read tangled tales. Materials Architecture Design Environment (MADE) 7, pp. 29-29.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2013. Birmingham City Library, Birmingham UK, Mecanoo architects. Architectural Review 234(1401), pp. 54-65.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2013. Function and decoration, tradition and invention: Carnegie Libraries and their architectural messages. Library and Information History 29(4), pp. 239-257. (10.1179/1758348913Z.00000000046)
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2012. Stuttgart City Library by Yi Architects. Architectural Review -London-
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2011. The secret life of libraries: Wisdom builds her house: the architecture and history of libraries, Architekturmuseum, Munich. Architectural Review -London-
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2011. Identity and spirit of Old Tbilisi [Blog]. Back of the Envelope 2011(12 May)
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2011. Typology Quarterly: Libraries. Architectural Review (2 Nov)
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2015. Four case studies demonstrating the impacts of energy conservation in traditional domestic buildings. In: Prizeman, O. E. C. ed. Sustainable Building Conservation: Theory and Practice of Responsive Design in the Heritage Environment.RIBA Publications.
- Whitman, C.et al. 2017. Improving the energy performance of historic timber-framed buildings in the UK. Presented at: Passive and Low Energy Architecture (PLEA) 2017, Edinburgh, UK, 3-5 July.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2016. The historic walled city of Ajmer, India: a case study in mapping tangible and intangible heritage for conservation planning. Presented at: The Association for Preservation Technology International Conference 2016, San Antonio, TX, USA, 30 October-2 November 2016.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. and Hardy, A. 2016. Rapid mapping and visual noise: recording for the visitor, resident, pilgrim and tourist; Ajmer, India (Work in Progress) - La cartografía rápida y ruido visual: grabación para el visitante, residente, peregrino y turístico; Ajmer, India (trabajo en curso). Presented at: 8th International Congress on Archaeology, Computer Graphics, Cultural Heritage and Innovation, Universitat Politècnica de València, Valencia, Spain, 5-7 September 2016. Published in: Lerma, J. and Cabrelles, M.eds. Proceedings: ARQUEOLÓGICA 2.0 - 8th International Congress on Archaeology, Computer Graphics, Cultural Heritage and Innovation. Valencia: Universitat Politècnica de València, pp. 372-375. (10.4995/arqueologica8.2016.4479)
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2016. Braided into the image: ritual depiction and continuous fabrication at Ajmer. Presented at: The European Association for South Asian Archaeology and Art, Cardiff, 4-8th July 2016.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2015. Performance values ancient and modern: four UK case studies. Presented at: Mettisage, Quebec City, QC, Canada, 26-29 October 2014.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2015. Deductive frameworks for a digital HBIM canon: matching specification standards to augment historic object libraries. Presented at: CIPA 25th International Symposium, Taipei, 31 Auggust - 4 September 2015.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2015. Carnegie libraries and the invention of a shared heritage. Presented at: Trans-Atlantic Dialogues on Cultural Heritage: Heritage, Tourism and Traditions, Liverpool, UK, 13-16 July 2015.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2015. Pubilc philanthropy: access not ownership. Presented at: Does this bridge belong to you?, Victoria and Albert Museum, London, UK, 22 May 2015.
- Whitman, C., Prizeman, O. E. C. and Walker, P. 2015. Interstitial hygrothermal conditions of low carbon retrofitting details for historic timber-framed buildings in UK. Presented at: Passive and Low Energy Architecture (PLEA) 2016, Bologna, Italy, 9-11 September 2015.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2014. Seeing and being seen: the radiant languages of public libraries. Presented at: Central Saint Martins Informal Exchange: 'Housing Information', Swiss Cottage Library, London, UK, 17 September 2014.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2014. Seeking models for the rehabilitation of collectively inhabited buildings. Presented at: 18th General Assembly and Scientific Symposium – "Heritage and Landscape as Human Values", Florence, Italy, 9 – 14 November 2014.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2012. Function and decoration, tradition and invention: Carnegie libraries and their architectural messages. Presented at: Buildings, Books and Blackboards: Intersecting Narratives, Melbourne, Australia, 28 November – 1 December 2012.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2012. Imagining purity. Presented at: Imagined Civities: Cities and Alternatives in the 19th Century, Cambridge, UK, 8 June 2012.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2011. Working with the Conservation Framework in Cambridge, England: A practitioner's view. Presented at: Identity and spirit of Old Tbilisi, Tbilisi, Georgia, 19 April - 2 May 2011.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2010. origins of daylight guidance: a dull English day?. Presented at: The Society for the History of Technology Conference 2010, Tacoma, WA, USA, 30 September - 2 October 2010.
- Prizeman, O. E. C. 2008. Influences on lighting performance: the case of the 1908 Carnegie Public Library at Wednesbury, Birmingham, UK. Presented at: Passive and low energy architecture, Dublin, Ireland, 2008 Passive and low energy architecture 2008 conference proceedings. Dublin: University College Dublin
- Whitman, C., Prizeman, O. E. C. and Lacey-Barnacle, M. 2016. Correlating maintenance, energy efficiency and fuel poverty for traditional buildings in the UK. Working paper. Cardiff: Welsh School of Architecture, Cardiff University.